• About
    • The Girl
    • The Blog
    • The One- Eared Bunny
    • The Philosophy
    • The FHB 12345 Challenge!
    • Giveaways
    • FAQs
    • DISCLAIMER
  • Recipes
    • Breakfast
    • Mains
    • Snacks
    • Soups/ Salads
    • Desserts/ Drinks
    • Lunchbox
      • Mealprep
      • Tools, Tips & Tricks
  • Eat Out!
    • Healthy Food Places in Singapore
    • Weekend Indulgences
  • Nutrition
    • Nutrition / Mental Health Articles
    • Mealplans
  • Wellness
    • Exercise
    • Fitness Products
    • Rest & Relax
  • Home
    • Cleaning and Organization
    • Kitchen Equipment Favs
    • Food Product Favs
  • Life
    • Travel
      • In Singapore
      • Japan
        • Tokyo
        • Osaka
        • Kyoto
    • Craft Addict
    • Personal
    • Wedding Planning
    • Social/ Environmental Awareness

Healthy Living in Singapore

June 30, 2013

Is Brown Rice Better than White Rice?

June 30, 2013

A lot of diets out there advocate a certain way of eating and
shunning specific food. Is added sugar really bad?
Should we avoid fried food forever? What about laksa? How about
Chocolate? Are egg yolks bad? Does eating healthy truly mean you can never
touch white rice again? Is brown rice, sugar, eggs, dogs and computers
really better than their white counterparts?

Well, let’s tackle this issue today!

Brown
rice has long been touted as THE rice to eat over white rice. White
rice, HORRORS! is an anti nutrient and must be avoided at ALL COST. But
oh, lovely brown rice is the darling of the wholegrain world. Unsullied
and unspoilt, it comes gleaming on your plate in all its unrefined
glory.

Taken from here

Taken from here

When grains go through refining, the bran
and germ are removed, effectively removing out fibre, B vitamins,
Minerals etc, leaving only the Endosperm which contains carbohydrates,
some protein and B vitamins.

As
you can see, brown rice trumps white rice on every front, calorie wise
as well but the differences are miniscule. White rice still gives you
more than 4g of protein and the carbohydrate levels are almost similar.
While
the Glycemic Index is different, the glycemic index of white rice can
actually be lowered by combining the rice with other fibrous food like
veggies etc. Since nobody usually eats plain white rice alone, that
shouldn’t really pose much of a problem. 
So what so bad about brown rice, or white rice, or grains in general? Why is it that most health advocates shun them?
Well, people generally eat very low fibre diets (see blog post on what singaporeans are eating daily) so swapping brown rice for white has added benefits in that it is a better alternative that white with it’s extra fibre and vitamins/ minerals. 
SO by swapping, you get an extra 2+g of fibre, 50mg more of magnesium, 60mg more of potassium etc. 
But if you are eating a diet of white rice TOGETHER with healthy vegetables etc that meet your daily fibre and mineral needs, then it’s not a matter of DEATH that you switch to brown. 
Conversely, if you are swapping white for brown and eating brown rice with a piece of fried chicken only, sure, it’s healthier because there is that little bit more of fibre and minerals but switching to brown is not going to MAGICALLY make you healthier or give you all the nutrients you need. 
There are also some people who cannot tolerate brown rice as the unrefined grain irritates their gut lining. It really depends on the individual. Personally, brown rice works for me because the added fibre helps steady my blood sugar levels because I don’t always have access to veg/ other fibre sources all the time. Whereas white rice is so soft and easy to eat that it’s really easy to overeat. It sends my ratios out of whack and my super sensitive blood sugar level will cause me to crave and want to stuff my face. A friend of mine, however, cannot tolerate brown rice at all as it irritates her gut and makes her feel thoroughly bloated and miserable. This makes her want to eat (other unhealthy things) to soothe the tummy pains and she feels better off eating white rice.
At the end of the day, just take a look at the Japanese. They eat lots of white rice but paired with healthy side dishes at every meal. It’s really up to the individual and what works best for you. White or brown, you need to look at what ELSE you are eating besides the rice that really makes the difference. 

Stay happy and healthy guys 🙂

<3

*Please read disclaimer. I do not claim to be a professional of any sort.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Posted by grace 6 Comments
Filed Under: Nutrition, Physical/ Mental Health Articles, Uncategorized Tagged: Brown Rice Vs. White Rice, Health Articles, Nutritional Information

Comments

  1. MEL~ says

    April 28, 2014 at 2:00 pm

    Hi, I love reading your blog!! Thank you so much for the helpful information~ I would like to try eating brown rice, do you have any brand of brown rice to recommend? Thank you!

    Reply
    • grace says

      May 15, 2014 at 1:35 am

      Thank you so much for your kind words! I'm going to do up a page soon about the brands I like and the products I usually eat. Will let you know when it's posted! But for now, I usually eat organic thai hom mali brown rice. you can google for the picture.It's sold at the kovan wet market in the dry provision stroe but I've seen it at other places as well. It has a cartoon elephant on the packaging! Haha. For starters, you can go to NTUC and try a small packet of the mixed rice as well just to ease your tastebuds into eating different grains! 🙂

      Reply
  2. Felix Chia says

    July 22, 2014 at 10:54 pm

    Browsing through, your blog has alot of good posts. You're spot on regarding the white vs brown rice issue. I too have started questioning the comparison.

    The "effect" of combining vegetables or other foods with a carbohydrate source is called Glycemic Load. The Glycemic Index is just a guide on 100g of carbohydrates of a certain food like white rice, brown rice etc as compared to glucose the gold standard.

    More importantly is the Glycemic Load, where the actual quantity consumed AND its Glycemic Load is taken into consideration. As you've mentioned, we don't eat just white rice alone and we also hardly eat 100g of carbohydrate (macronutrient not physical weight) at one go.

    With the Glycemic Load, portion control and moderation shows how important it is. Because consuming more of a Low GI food, will increase the load compared to consuming a lesser amount of a High GI food. But of course for the same amount of carbohydrates, Low GI is a healthier alternative at least for general meals with no specific dietary requirements.

    The emphasis on nutrition should be on balanced, portion, and healthier choices. However for public health, where sadly people are generally more educated and know what to do, it's the influence of popular culture, society and habits from young that are the big obstacles.

    It's how to truly compete with popular, great tasting and desirable food. I wish to change that. Slowly …

    Reply
    • grace says

      July 28, 2014 at 7:03 am

      Haha thanks for dropping by and for the great write up here! I should totally invite you to guest blog here! We could all benefit from your wealth of knowledge!

      Reply
  3. Eleona says

    August 28, 2014 at 7:42 am

    Hi, you have a nice blog here… i stumbled on your blog as i am looking for the GI info. of Hom Mali Brown rice… Lately, i was diagnosed with gestational diabetes at my 30th week pregnancy so my gynae recommended me to switch my intake of white rice to brown rice. But after some search online, not all brown rice has low GI. Some site even mentioned some brown rice have high GI. I wondered if you have the actual GI count for Hom Mali Brown rice? I just bought a 2kg pack from NTUC but it did not state its GI level…

    Reply
    • grace says

      August 28, 2014 at 12:29 pm

      Hi there!

      congrats on the new baby! I'm sure you must be very excited! 😀

      It's unfortunate about the gestational diabetes but there are many ways to handle it. I don' tnow about the brown rice's actual GI count but brown rice in general has a GI count of 55-85 depending on how processed it is. To ease your fears, I would say that the GI value of the rice doesn't really matter much but it's what you pair with it that matters. Also, the hom mali is a real type of brown rice. Some brown rice have high GI because unethical suppliers actually colour their white rice darken to make it look healthy!

      The GI value of the food is based on that food BY ITSELF. So eating white rice alone will impact your sugar levels drastically because of it's high GI but this can be mitigated by pairing it with fibre rich food, protein or good fats such that it slows the impact on blood sugar levels.

      The Thai Hom Mali brown rice is one of my favorites in terms of flavour and I recommend that you enjoy it as well paired with lean protein and fibre rich sides! On a standard round dinner plate, 1/2 a section should be ALL leafy veg/ broccoli etc, 1/4 meat and 1/4 brown rice. If you can handle it, i personally recommend subbing the brown rice for steel cut oat porridge sometimes maybe for variety. What you want to always make sure is to have carbohydrates with fibre to slow the release which means hawker centre porridge is possibly the worst thing you can eat because of it's high sodium and fat content + high GI.

      I hope this information has been useful! Don't stress and do enjoy the last few weeks of pregnancy! Is this your first child? 🙂

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hello There!

Hi! My name is Grace
and I live in sunny Singapore! :D Welcome to Fithealthybunny.com where I share my love for exploring, healthy eating, mindful living and everything in between

Should you have a question
or need a listening ear,
fithealthybunny@gmail.com
will always be open for you :)

xoxo

Top Posts & Pages

  • The problem with the Singaporean Diet
    The problem with the Singaporean Diet
  • Lunchbox Meal Prep- Prep Once, Eat All Week!- Week 1: Tips to get started
    Lunchbox Meal Prep- Prep Once, Eat All Week!- Week 1: Tips to get started
  • Healthy Mealprep FAQ: Precut Vegetables and Nutrient Loss
    Healthy Mealprep FAQ: Precut Vegetables and Nutrient Loss
  • Natural Healings - Holistic health and wellness in Singapore!
    Natural Healings - Holistic health and wellness in Singapore!
  • Minus Calories Workout at ActiveHive Singapore!
    Minus Calories Workout at ActiveHive Singapore!

FHB on Instagram! :D

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Error: No connected account.

Please go to the Instagram Feed settings page to connect an account.

‘Like’ FHB on Facebook!

‘Like’ FHB on Facebook!

Theme by 17th Avenue · Powered by WordPress & Genesis